Deteriorating Building Slated for Teardown Cost Proposals

The River Edge council unanimously approved to seek proposals for a cost estimate to tear down the Walter Scott Brown American Legion building

Bought and paid for three years ago in an "as is" condition, the deteriorating American Legion building on Continental Avenue in River Edge is nearing its final days. The River Edge Mayor and Council approved in a 5-0 vote to go forward and seek cost estimates on tearing it down. Councilman Edward Mignone was absent from the vote.

"It could cost three times as much to fix it," Councilman Paul Cordts said. "At this time, so we can move forward, we should look to take it down and use the property for a better use before it becomes an eyesore."

In agreement with Cordts was Councilman Alphonse Bartelloni who suggested the borough look to eventually invest funding in expanding the Public Library and architect Peter Pulice who was hired to review the status of the American Legion.

The Dutch Colonial-style building is approximately between 80 to 90 years old but is along with not being ADA compliant.

"There is quite a bit of runoff that finds its way into the basement so there is mold and water infiltration issues," Pulice said. "It has a low ceiling in the basement and the current topography limits accessibility from an ADA standpoint. It would require a pretty substantial ramp system to be devised for entry from the parking lot."

In the past, the council had received Community Development Block Grants towards the initial purchase and goal of transforming the American Legion into a . In March, the governing body voted to seeking additional grants.

Pulice estimated that with the amount of work needed to make the building viable for public use, costs could run anywhere between $300,000 to $1.3 million. Along with mold remediation and bringing the building into ADA compliance, the duct work is exposed on the exterior, there is a need for new windows and roof, proper building insulation, repairs to the foundation, and electrical work. The American Legion also does not meet current borough codes as well for fire safety or ventilation.

"Due to the high water table, I would not recommend digging out the basement as it would make the infiltration problem more chronic," Pulice said. "You would need to excavate around the exterior, utilize a high level of drainage or storm water management to divert the water away.

"In my opinion and experience, renovating an older building costs more than building a new one," Pulice continued. "There are so many issues to deal with for retrofitting. I don't see the point in improving the building or spending huge amounts of money to make it work. It should probably just be removed at this point, that's just my opinion."

Once potential cost estimates have been received for tearing down the American Legion, the Council will continue its discussion on moving forward.

Frances Kasturas February 10, 2012 at 04:06 PM
I'm compelled to write, concerning the proposed demolition of the American Legion building in River Edge. I came to River Edge in '48 at the age of 6. My late father built a still thriving business in River Edge. The American Legion holds a special place in my heart and, I'm sure, the hearts of others in River Edge. Memories 'live' in the now deteriorating building. The American Legion has 'sentimental VALUE,' which should be addressed, & reconsidered. My memories are of Girl Scout meetings, Patriotic events & club meetings, We celebrated engagement & weddings, surprise birthdays & anniversaries, bridal & baby showers. We mourned at repast dinners. Is there no room for sentiment' in the discussion? I lived in River Edge for 53 years & moved to Sussex County when my husband retired. But I've said many times, "My roots grow deep in River Edge;' it's still 'my town,' and as the song goes (I paraphrase), 'I left my heart in River Edge.' I visit otten and the loss of this building makes me very sad. Wouldn't it be great if it could be preserved & put to good use? A Senior Center sounds great. How many RE residents feel the same about its PRESERVATION? By todays standards, the cost of $300,000 to 1.3 million dollars sounds reasonable, to preserve a beautiful, historic & beloved early 1900's building. Why has the grant search been abandoned? My purpose in writing is to urge reconsideration. Save this building! That's MY opinion. Frances Mamounes Kasturas 973-827-0328
Lewis Jacobus February 11, 2012 at 07:15 PM
$300,000 to $1,300,000, pretty good guess! Lew Jacobus
Richard Lombardo February 12, 2012 at 01:00 PM
I moved to Oradell in 1956, but my grandparents lived on Continental Ave. 1/4 mile from the American Legion Building. I remember playing baseball on the Little League field there, and tennis too! Going to "record hop" dances there while at River Dell High! It would be a shame for the building to be demolished. I'm sure there are so many memories for so many people there.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »